Bread of the day: Wholemeal 5 seeded

I fell in love with baking bread at the same time as I discovered growing things from seed. I get the same tactile pleasure from kneading dough as I do from being up to my wrists in earth. I usually have either dough or dirt under my fingernails – and sometimes both… A couple of weeks ago I mentioned baking bread in a post and Christina asked me to post my bread recipes so that we could share. I’d been meaning to blog about bread occasionally anyway, and decided it was high time I got around to it, so here is a start.

River Cottage Bread Book by Daniel Stevens

When I began I followed a Nigel Slater recipe, and turned out flattened domes of dense chewy bread. Tasty but not attractive, and certainly no competition for a good quality loaf from a good baker. But at least I knew exactly what was in it – just flour, yeast, salt and water – and had the pleasure of creating it. As with growing things, I have learnt a lot since then. Best of all, I bought myself the River Cottage Bread book by Daniel Stevens. It transformed my bread-making. He takes a full chapter to explain the basic bread recipe, what ingredients to use, how to shape a loaf, everything you need to make good bread. And it really works! I now make all kinds of bread, including ciabatta, walnut, peanut, not to mention great pizza bases, biscuits, bread sticks. But our every day bread, the one I am making today and make every week, is a wholemeal five seeded loaf.

The basic recipe follows the standard baker’s percentage but I use a little white flour to lighten the loaf slightly and add in a mix of seeds:

700g Wholemeal organic bread flour

300g Strong white organic flour

10g dry yeast

20g fine sea salt

600ml warm water

One handful each of poppy seeds, linseeds, sesame seeds, sunflower seeds and pumpkin seeds

Sponge Stage
Pre Kneaded

I use the sponge method for my 5 seeded bread, as it seems to give a deeper flavour and fits well into my daily life. This involves mixing half the flour (for me, 500g wholemeal) with all of the yeast and all of the warm water to make a rather unappetising glop, covering it with a (clean!) bin liner and leaving it out in the kitchen over night. The yeast starts to ferment and multiply, so that when you come down in the morning you are faced with a glop now full of bubbles and smelling slightly like a brewery. Now you add the rest of the flour, the salt, and in my case the seeds, and mix to form a rough dough. Sometimes enough water has been lost over night that I have to add a little more to make the dough nice and moist.

Shaped For Proving
Post Proving

Ten minutes or so of kneading transforms the dough, turning it from rough and unpromising into smooth and elastic. I think this is my favourite part of the process, and I frequently lose myself in thought, often daydreaming about the garden and what I need to do next, kneading for closer to 15 minutes. The now pliable dough is shaped into a tight round – a key tip from Dan Steven’s book – and put back under its bin liner to double in size. I love the apparent alchemy of this, it reminds me of the way that you sow seed and then as if by magic it sprouts into the green shoots of the new garden. Knowing the underlying science in no way diminishes the pleasure. This rising takes anything from an hour to three, depending on the temperature. I rather like the unpredictability of it all, though it can be a problem if I am working to some sort of deadline – like lunch…

Shaped For Baking

Next comes the shaping and proving. I like smallish loaves, it gives a higher crust to bread ratio, which in a household where everyone wants the fresh crust helps maintain a certain degree of harmony! I divide the risen dough into 3, shape each portion into a tight round and leave, covered by that bin liner, to rest for 15 minutes. I would never have known to do this without the book, but it seems to really help. Each round is then shaped into a stubby cylinder, rolled in a little milk and then in some pumpkin seeds, and placed on a floured board (under that bin liner) to prove. I was getting problems with loaves splitting during the proving stage, but some advice from the River Cottage forum suggested I was leaving the loaves for too long. Now I tend to only leave them for just over an hour, until they have almost doubled in size and are springy to the touch.

Now the oven gets turned up to top whack with a large heavy baking tray inside and an old tin on the shelf below it. I boil the kettle, make sure I have a plant sprayer full of water to hand and gently slash the top of each loaf. The tops spring apart proving that the yeast is still alive and well. Now comes the only bit of the process that I don’t really enjoy. Transferring the loaves to the baking tray. I used to get really panicky at this point, as I’d read dire warnings about needing to be careful about not knocking all the air out. And yes, you do have to be gentle, but actually the loaves rise a lot in the first few minutes in the oven, so it is not nearly as desperate as I used to think. So, each loaf is gently lifted on to the piping hot baking tray, sprayed with water, and the tray replaced in the oven. The boiling water from the kettle is poured into the old tray on the bottom shelf to add steam, the door closed, and timer set for 10 minutes. When the buzzer goes, the oven gets turned down to between 190C and 170C, depending on how quickly they are colouring, and the timer reset for around 20 minutes. By this time the smell is filling the house and people tend to start appearing in the doorway looking hopeful…

Sliced Five Seeded

The final product is a tasty wholemeal bread, perfect toasted or for sandwiches, with no preservatives. It costs a fraction of what the equivalent loaf from an artisan baker would be, and I get the joy of making it. Each loaf is slightly different, and sometimes I forget to slash the tops and they split in the oven, or I don’t leave the dough to rise enough and the loaves are a tad too dense. But I could never go back to buying bread having discovered what fun it is to bake my own. Would I still do it if I worked full time? I think so, as it doesn’t actually take much time. Perhaps 20 minutes to weigh, mix and knead, then later – and it can be much later – another 10 minutes to shape. I think the timing would be the most difficult thing, as you do need to be around to check during proving, and you do need to be around for the half hour or so around actually baking the loaves, but it is so worth it…

8 Comments


  1. Janet thanks again for dropping by my blog girl !
    I love your bread : ) I wish I could do that too but it would be too painful for me to knead so I appreciate how much work it can be for you to do this .. and take such great pictures too ! .. I used to have a wonderful .. simple .. recipe for whole wheat scones .. now that one I could manage to turn out enough to make the circle and precut the wedges .. I put raisins in and manged to even get my little one to it it way back then when he didn’t know about fast food ? LOL
    I love this post .. it is perfect for a windy gray day we are having here in Kingston .. I have to have my red flannel penguin jim jams on ! hahaha
    Joy : )


    1. Hi Joy. Mixer with a dough hook? Or even a bread maker? I have lots of friends who use a bread maker to do the heavy mixing part and turn out gorgeous bread. Adding pain into the recipe would not be good! I want your pyjamas…


  2. Mmmmmmmm ~ I can almost smell that the aroma of newly baked bread Janet :) I have not tried baking a loaf for some time but must give it another go. Will be investigating the book forthwith.


    1. Go for it! You won’t regret it – and neither will your friends and family!


  3. Never related kneading dough to digging in the dirt but what a good pair. The bread sure looks hearty enough to give you some good energy to go dig. I’d love to smell your house-I bet it is always smelling great!


    1. Hi Tina – it is certainly good fuel! Just had some toasted for breakfast…


  4. Hi Janet, we make all our own bread but I think you are rather more advanced than I am! Looks great, love the seeds! Thanks for your comment on my expert or dilettante blog. I agree with you I think. Attractive though the idea is of being a real expert on something, I love the range of things that I do.


  5. Hi Janet; If getting out of bed early on frosty mornings is not your thing, surely the prospect of some toast made with your own home-made bread (perhaps with some of your own home-made Seville orange marmalade) would be sufficient inducement? [I agree with you that the River Cottage books are good. Got most of them now]

Comments are closed.